| Evelyn | Barclay | UK | thank you for such an interesting website. |
| Evelyn | Hay | UK | |
| Eileen | Mathews | AU | The war memorial is magnificent. Will make sure I see it on my next visit to Scotland. |
| Gina | Mayers | UK | In memory of my grandfather George Grayson of the 6th Batt. Seaforth Highlanders, who died on the 19th January 1944 at Monte Cassino, whom I never got to meet, but I am so proud of you granddad, and love you very much. Your granddaughter Gina (nee grayson)from Liverpool |
| Mhairi | Stewart | UK | Thank you for the upkeep of this Memorial. I shall visit Edinburgh Castle very soon. |
| Stephen | Cowie | -- | |
| Jean | Tapiolas | AU | |
| David | Robertson | NZ | |
| Alan | Bennett | UK | |
| Norah | David | US | I was overcome with emotion when the name of one of my uncles appeared on the page. I found all three of these brave young Scottish men remembered and honored by your Memorial and my memories from my parents. |
| Frederick | Lamb | NZ | I am trying to trace My Father Killed WW11 |
| Lois | Marienau | US | I am looking for a name on the Edinburgh list of war dead names Jepson, Banks, or Thorpe dies in the 1st World War |
| Keven | Draper | AU | john baillie, lumphinnians,scotland K.I.A. kdraper medal curator royal south australia regiment& sth australia mounted rifles &keswick army barracks museum 7 |